top of page

Friendsgiving Catering in NJ: How to Host 15 to 40 Friends Without Cooking All Day

Writer: Nicole P.
Nicole P.
1 day ago
5 min read

Friendsgiving has become a holiday of its own. It's the dinner where you choose the guest list: college roommates, neighbors, coworkers who became friends, and anyone who can't make it home for Thanksgiving. It's relaxed, a little noisy, and usually happens the weekend before or after the big day.


What it shouldn't be is a second Thanksgiving's worth of cooking. If you're hosting Friendsgiving in Asbury Park, Spring Lake, Manalapan, Point Pleasant or anywhere in Monmouth and Ocean County, catering the main dishes lets you spend the night with your friends instead of your oven. Here's how to plan it.


The Short Answer: How to Cater a Friendsgiving


Decide whether you want a full catered dinner or just the heavy lifting (the main protein and the time-consuming sides). Plan about 4 to 5 ounces of protein per guest and two to three sides, let friends bring drinks or one favorite dish, and order at least 24 to 48 hours ahead, since Foodinis doesn't offer same-day delivery.


Pick Your Friendsgiving Style


Not every Friendsgiving looks the same. Choose the format first, and the menu follows.


Style

Best for

What to order

Sit-down dinner

10–20 friends around one big table

Hot buffet: a main protein, two or three sides, salad, dessert

Casual buffet

20–40 guests mingling around the house

Hot buffet served from chafing dishes, plus a dessert platter

Grazing party

Open-house style, people coming and going

Hors d'oeuvres, platters and finger desserts

Half catered, half potluck

Groups who love bringing a signature dish

Caterer covers the main and sides; friends bring drinks, bread or pie


The half-and-half approach is the most popular for Friendsgiving: it keeps the potluck spirit without the risk of eight desserts and no main dish.


Build a Friendsgiving Menu That Feels Like the Holiday


A Friendsgiving table needs the classics, with room for everyone's eating style.


The centerpiece


  • Roast turkey or a roast chicken entrée

  • A second protein, such as a beef dish or glazed ham, for the non-turkey crowd

  • A hearty vegetarian main, so plant-based friends get a real plate


The sides everyone fights over


  • Mashed or roasted potatoes

  • Stuffing

  • Green beans or roasted seasonal vegetables

  • Mac and cheese, the side that always disappears first


Something fresh and something sweet


  • A crisp autumn-style salad to balance the richer dishes

  • Pies, cookies or a dessert platter


Browse our hot entrée packages for buffet mains and sides, our hors d'oeuvres for a grazing-style party, and our desserts for the sweet finish. Ask about seasonal and holiday items when you order, since availability can change in late November.


Planning tip: Assign potluck slots instead of leaving it open. "You bring wine, you bring rolls, you bring your famous pie" covers the gaps and keeps the table balanced.

How Much Food Do You Need for Friendsgiving?


Foodinis portions hot entrées at about 4 to 5 ounces of protein per person, 3 to 4 ounces of each side and 6 to 7 ounces of starch, and a half-pan serves roughly 8 to 12 people. Friendsgiving guests tend to go back for seconds, so plan generously.


Guests

Main proteins

Sides

Salad and dessert

15

2 half-pans (turkey or chicken plus a second option)

3 sides, 1–2 half-pans each

1 salad, 1 dessert platter

25

3–4 half-pans

3 sides, 2–3 half-pans each

2 salads, 2 dessert platters

40

5–6 half-pans

3–4 sides, 3–4 half-pans each

3 salads, 3 dessert platters


If friends are bringing sides, trim the catered sides by one dish. For a deeper breakdown, see our guide on how much food you need for 20, 30, 50 or 100 guests.


Don't Forget the Details


  • Dietary needs: Ask about allergies when you send the invite. Many Foodinis dishes are naturally gluten-free, vegetarian or vegan, and allergies can be noted at checkout.

  • Drinks: Friends often bring wine, but add water, iced tea or sodas from our beverages menu so non-drinkers are covered.

  • Plates and serving pieces: Serving utensils are included. Add plates, napkins, cutlery, cups and chafing dishes from the Miscellaneous section at checkout, so you're not running the dishwasher at midnight.

  • Keeping food hot: Each wire chafing setup comes with two sterno cans and a water pan and keeps food hot for about two hours, which covers a relaxed dinner.

  • Reheating: Prefer to serve on your own timing? Ask about cold drop-off with heating instructions.

  • Leftovers: Keep to-go containers on hand. Sending friends home with a plate is half the fun.


Do It Yourself or Hire a Caterer?


Cooking for six friends is a fun challenge. Cooking for 25 means two days of shopping, prepping and juggling one oven, and spending the party in the kitchen.


Most Friendsgivings work best as drop-off catering: the food arrives ready to serve in the 15-minute delivery window you choose, and you pick "set-up required" or "set-up not required" at checkout. Want servers so you can be a guest at your own party? Staffed events need at least three weeks' notice, so keep that in mind for next year's Friendsgiving or your holiday party.


Planning Friendsgiving in Monmouth County?


Foodinis is a chef-owned catering company in Neptune City, led by CIA-trained Chef John Deatcher, who has been seen on NBC's Today Show and Food Network's Chopped. Since 2007 we've been cooking for gatherings across Monmouth and Ocean Counties, delivered by our own in-house team. Our kitchen is inspected by the Monmouth County Health Department, and our chefs and cooks are ServSafe certified.


Hosting the family Thanksgiving dinner too? Our guide to Thanksgiving and holiday dinner catering in NJ covers the big day.


Frequently Asked Questions


What is Friendsgiving?


Friendsgiving is a Thanksgiving-style meal shared with friends instead of family, usually held the weekend before or after Thanksgiving. It's typically more casual, and often part potluck.


What should I serve at Friendsgiving?


A roast turkey or chicken main, a second protein or vegetarian entrée, two or three comfort sides like mashed potatoes, stuffing and mac and cheese, a fresh salad and dessert. Let friends bring drinks, bread or a signature dish.


How much food do I need for Friendsgiving for 25 people?


Plan about three to four half-pans of protein split between two options, three sides at two to three half-pans each, two salads and two dessert platters. Each Foodinis half-pan serves roughly 8 to 12 people.


How far ahead should I order Friendsgiving catering?


Order as early as you can, and at least 24 to 48 hours ahead. Foodinis doesn't offer same-day delivery, and the weeks around Thanksgiving are busy. Orders can be placed up to eight weeks in advance.


Can I mix catering with a potluck?


Yes. Many hosts cater the main protein and the time-consuming sides, then ask friends to bring drinks, rolls or dessert. It keeps the potluck spirit and guarantees a complete meal.


Can Foodinis accommodate vegetarian and gluten-free guests?


Yes. Many dishes are naturally vegetarian, vegan or gluten-free, and you can note allergies and simple ingredient changes at checkout. See our FAQ page for details.


Host a Friendsgiving Everyone Remembers


Gather your people, skip the two days in the kitchen, and actually sit down for the toast. Order online in a few minutes and pick your delivery window.



Questions about your menu or delivery? Contact the Foodinis team and we'll help you plan it.

Comments


bottom of page